Massachsuetts Noncompetition Agreements Tougher to Enforce

Massachusetts law controls noncompetition agreements, with clear guidelines to be met in order to be enforceable.  The statute can be understood as permitting employers to protect themselves from abuse, but protecting employees from becoming de facto unemployable and insolvent.  (This statutory scheme does not apply to a principal of a company, working as an employee of the company,  upon sale of that company; different issues not below addressed come into play upon an acquisition.)

Basic statutory rule for enforceability: Noncomps must be in writing, signed by employer and employee, must provide fair consideration for support of the employee while sidelined (often in the form of a so-called payment scheme known as “garden leave”), and the agreement must be signed at least ten business days  before end of employment and after employee has been afforded notice that they are entitled to a lawyer.

New Case: About ten days ago the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled that an employer cannot enforce a noncomp against an employee where the signatory on behalf of the employer was by the parent entity of the actual employing business.  The obligation for signature falls on the actual employer, not its parent; this, even though the employee itself signed the agreement.

It is not hard to see how the facts in the court case arose, as it is not unusual for an employee of a subsidiary to receive a right to obtain equity shares in the parent holding company.  But the Court held that, even though the parent company appropriately signed the agreements relating to shares of stock, the employing subsidiary had to itself execute the noncomp.

One might conclude that such a statutory reading is very restrictive and perhaps illogical; after all the employee upon signature did intend to be bound to a noncomp and failure of a subsidiary signature feels like a foot-fault.  I suspect, however, that the Court was interested in clarity in all cases when someone is asked to sign a noncomp, particularly in light of the history of the underlying Massachusetts statute: when adopted, it was viewed as a strong statement of policy to provide protections to an employee who had few other powers of defense in the typical case.

This decision does not alter prior law that requires an employee to protect and keep confidential trade secrets, to refrain from marketing clients of a prior employer, and to refrain from disparagement of a former employer.

Finally, safety and logic on behalf of employers suggests that at every stage of process wherein a noncomp will be involved the name and signature of both parent entity and employing entity be included.  Seems the Mass SJC is pretty picky about enforcing rights of employees as reflected in the statute, and clarity and completeness seem the order of the day….

 

Comments are closed.